Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
小场景的多方对峙警匪片，开局还不错，可惜20分钟后期待开始逐渐消减了，不到一小时第四方反派出现后迅速变为无趣。多方关系拉得一点都不紧绷，三个主角感觉像在玩一样，靠说一些无关紧要的骚话来侧面衬托专业素质这种做法真的一点都不专业，只有一种试图营造运筹帷幄却沦为明晃晃的主角光环既视感。第四个老头杀手更是脸谱化到极点，我的理解是导演想塑造一个小丑型的戏谑混乱反派，只能恭喜导演倒是塑造了一个真正的小丑吧。整部片的后半段就是看几个角色无限装逼，然而装得又缺乏魅力，即便是从装逼、中二这单方面来看，都不及格。
3/5。看着拉尔夫费因斯一把年纪费劲的演着，出于对他的喜爱，多给一个🌟。大反派没有好好写只是做了类型处理，很二yuan论，也许符合的是当时的逻辑？治腿和对打拉斯普丁那一段其实拍的趣味横生，壮汉芭蕾这么搭配原来也可。为了子嗣重新“做人”这个概念太古典了，大概只能在宣扬不要撒谎要做绅士一夫一妻的p**国，catho国家人士看了大概会说，我外面的情f还有几个儿子呢………感觉这是部先导片，续集还在后面排队？
我看有翻译成正义陷落的，看了演职员表，瞬间明白了，确实应该叫陷落…看完突然有个想法，把杰哥演的这些xx陷落组个宇宙，主角也都由男主一个人演，然后自己打自己，来个大逃杀，不比三虫同框带劲？
陷落哥这次动作片不动作了～感觉像剧集导演拍了个电影。
WHAT THE FUCK (in a good way) (but also in a bad way what the fuck) Someone def made this when they’re on really poor quality acid
同样的题材，与《血溅13号警署》相比，这片就显得过于矫情了
看封面就知道国内翻译肯定有“陷落”俩字，果然……正义陷落，呆呆警察局可能更适合
分数：65
黑警、疯子、杀手，泰日天最可恨，但凡有一丟丟良心，先给女主找急救包啊，斯巴达给他报仇收了人头，还笃悠悠吃她的便当，真TM不是人养的，建议冷锋可以再S1W次。
设在荒郊野岭的警察局，改成监狱或许更合逻辑。骗子、追捕者和杀手在警局大开杀戒的设定是很合观众胃口的，可惜拍烂了……
不用太考虑剧情，这是一部很酷的片子，黑人女主表演亮眼。
我看有翻译成正义陷落的，看了演职员表，瞬间明白了，确实应该叫陷落…看完突然有个想法，把杰哥演的这些xx陷落组个宇宙，主角也都由男主一个人演，然后自己打自己，来个大逃杀，不比三虫同框带劲？
整体看下来挺不错的，所有场景基本上都发生在了警局，警察有好有坏，杀手有正常的也有变态的，诈骗犯成了最后的坏蛋。剧情设计的也比较合理，各个人物的演技也挺到位的，尤其那个变态杀手演的真好，正常的那个杀手人设也设置的很到位，不是一味的无脑。动作戏看的很过瘾，最后的结局也不落窠臼，留有余地。
5/10分动作片,看了10分钟才敢确定男配是交叉叔,自毁形象简直太扣分了,Gerard Butler真越来越帅了,但在前半程居然毫无亮点,Toby Huss出场可以说是拯救了该片,却也难抵结尾过多反转的无趣,最后查看演员表万万没想到Ryan O'Nan又双演了个肥腻,男演员们究竟是中了什么风,失重风吗?
看到演员有Gerard Butler就看了。剧情紧凑，小黑妹勇敢有原则，也很酷。好看好看。我也想像小黑妹那么酷。😁😁😁
【2022/05/19 英国编剧真能编】
小成本电影，也没能拍出大反馈，故事比较平。一般吧
都不能把觀眾當成只吃垃圾的白痴
爆米花电影也称不上劲爆啊，总差那么一口气没让人爽起来
前传与前两部的风格迥然不同，变成了对历史的戏说，斐迪南大公遇刺、俄国十月革命、拉斯普京乱政、白宫艳照门、以及最后彩蛋希特勒与列宁的会晤……整体还是平庸无趣，亮点在于三人合战芭蕾舞魔僧拉斯普京，略显cult气质。
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
