The issue of War widow representation in Israeli cinema is one of the most complex for the local industry for it seems to be unique and with a very local and specific iconography.
The war Widow is a difficult character to digest. Because this is an especially painful topic in Israel, its mode of representation is almost always problematic.
Gila Almagor in Tofano's "siege" is one of the first characters of the "modern" war widows to appear on Israeli cinema screens.
The human and social complexity of the status of widows was not represented adequately and personally until her complex and fine appearance in this film.
It was mostly Preceded by cliches of heroic women who have sacrificed for the nation with characters to which it was very difficult to get attached, nor to their personal grief.
"Siege" was directed by an unknown Italian director of that period. Although Gilberto Tofano was brought as a professional director on the wings of inspiration made by the French New Wave of those years, he managed to turn out a very exciting work which has caught the Israeli warmth and sense of social siege which surrounds the Israeli widows, including the great expectations from them and the social stigmas.
Tofano wrapped his leading lady with lots of warmth and gave a place of honor to Almagor's impressive presence in the film.
This is without a doubt one of Almagor's best and most accurate performances. The restraint in her performance plus the shooting and expressive use of angles by Tofano and his soft European touch which was far off from the aggressive local product managed to produce a sense of documenting an authentic tragedy with a tangible personal touch that minimized the national dimension. The result stands the test of time proudly several decades after its creation.
一般般，剧情也感觉一般般不难看，也不突出。算是一部中规中矩的正常电影，低成本能做成这样子也很不错了
这个导演还可以，过往有合格作品，女主是星二代，故事很简单，带着两个孩子的年轻母亲住在乡下旧宅，前夫和恶友来访，母亲大战两人，其中有一段剧情是一次很好的尝试，母亲被困杂物间，小空间看一个人表演，其他方面比较普通，6.2
這種套娃式的荒誕太歡樂了！人在現實和虛構中的處境是荒誕而尷尬的；電影在現實和虛構中的處境也是荒誕而尷尬的。縮減到100分鐘以內比較合適，兩個多小時確實太長了，很多地方銜接得其實挺生硬的，就只能各種尬舞尬演。這部電影是對疫情下影視行業一種淺白的嘲解，荒誕熱鬧又帶幾分無奈，包含了眾多社交媒體和演員梗，放低預期當成惡搞片看會比較開心。
还真是某种意义上的网飞自黑了 笑点还是有 就是再紧凑点就好了 这种主题配上这种时常很难不让人觉得疲软了
密室逃脱型的片子，女主最后反杀，宗教的寓意很明显，基本全程无尿点，值得三星，可以一看。
哎，一言难尽...我为啥要看？(||๐_๐)
(小baby也太可爱了，叫的人心都融化了)
哎，一言难尽...我为啥要看？(||๐_๐)
20220602 周四 19:52 只能说我是为了vincent而看的他，他现在是不是已经不混电影圈啦，多久没看见他有作品了，都已经60岁了呢，在戏里演人渣而且他奇奇怪怪的出场又莫名其妙的死去，哎呀！女主有点像Alexa chung，不过演技好差！我想说苹果坏了一般即使保留了一半好的部分其实它也是烂的了。
真的很好笑为什么分这么低！前面慢一点但是后面整个爆笑，可能隔离过的人才能体会！凯伦吉兰果然手脚不怎么协调哈哈哈
封校的时候看到这个真的太能感同身受了，真的想逃跑 片尾还蛮给人希望的 希望两年后真的会变好吧……
美丽国网大也是这水平嘛～讲诉烂片是怎么拍成的烂片，全方位讽刺，包括自己，也是笑了
50/100 有有趣的部分 但是也有无聊到死的部分。创意不错 但是不足以拍2个小时 中间有段时间一直在2倍速。感觉拍成电视剧会更好。
一些关于隔离的片段确实会另人感同身受，期待今日浦西解封。🙏
以后还是要少看这种没什么剧情，两三个人就在两三个场景里的电影儿
就是那种一打开就知道 “我是网络大电影”
这种密闭空间题材的电影，小空间里更容易创造出更多的张力。还喜欢这种戛然而止没有结局，这个题材的电影这是必然。
第十三天居家隔离，脑残快乐但至少乐过，就这样吧。我家一美客串太惊喜啦~
整体和不要抬头既是一类片子也是差不多的完成度，部分笑点和脑洞还可以，但整体偏温吞无趣，而且作为喜剧节奏有问题，篇幅过长了，看到后期甚至能与片中角色的漫长感产生共情
没有任何演技支撑起女主心理活动，所有行动都不合常理，你说她紧张没看出来，她愤怒你没看出来，演技差的让人发指。还假装高级带了一下宗教，试图升华，爬上去脱困还故意来个破茧重生的场面，然后各种骚操作，小孩不见了跟圣诞节拆礼物似的，莫名其妙带着小孩外面淋雨，当然家里死了两个人最后的岁月静好也让你佩服
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
